Episode 1

Host Jack Wagner welcomes JC, Anna, Ricky, Jodi, Monica, and Laura to the Christmas Cookie Matchup kitchen. Bakers are tasked with their first mini-bake challenge then paired with the cast of When Calls the Heart.

Episode 2

Bakers are challenged with decorating gingerbread cookies for their mini bake, and the winning baker receives assistance from a surprise guest. For the main bake, teams create a beautifully festive winter wonderland scene.

Episode 3

Bakers tackle a delicious Hallmark published recipe for their mini-bake, and the winner chooses a member of the When Calls the Heart cast from Cookie Corner to assist with their next holiday challenge.

Episode 4

Judges will determine who makes the best chocolate chip cookie, and the winner will receive a set of helping hands for their next holiday challenge. Teams interpret letters to Santa and present some delightful creations.

Episode 5

Two bakers are tasked with a no-bake challenge, competing for a cash prize. The bakers also get some extra help from Cookie Corner, which comes in handy for their final bake.