Episode 1

Casey Webb challenges three teams of Christmas bakers to create fantasy snow globe cakes that capture the magic and joy of the holidays. Each team uses ice sculpture to enhance the glitz and glam of their display and impress judges Jocelyn Delk Adams, Amanda Freitag and Zac Young. The team with the winning cake advances to the grand finale.

Episode 2

Mrs. Claus has finished her Christmas preparations, and Casey Webb challenges three teams of master holiday bakers and their ice sculptors to show off a new side of Santa's better half in out-of-this-world cake designs and displays. The teams pull out all the stops to impress judges Jocelyn Delk Adams, Amanda Freitag and Zac Young, and the most impressive cake advances one team to the grand finale.

Episode 3

Casey Webb challenges three teams of Christmas bakers and their ice sculptors to create colossal Christmas tree cake displays complete with edible presents, ornaments and pyrotechnics. The team whose creation impresses judges Jocelyn Delk Adams, Amanda Freitag and Zac Young the most advances to the grand finale.

Episode 4

It's the night before Christmas, and Santa Claus is coming to town! Casey Webb challenges the three remaining baking teams and their ice sculptors to create the ultimate night before Christmas cake display featuring the big man himself. Judges Jocelyn Delk Adams, Amanda Freitag and Zac Young watch as the teams escalate their designs to make the most memorable Christmas cake on record and win the $25,000 prize. (!)